Revenue Cycle Complexity

Why Most Revenue Cycles Are Broken, and How to Rehab Yours

If your practice depends on third-party payers, you are not a physical therapy practice with a billing team. You are a revenue cycle business that performs physical therapy for revenue. After connecting to revenue cycles now in the thousands, I can tell you that the vast majority of them are broken. Not because the people are bad at their jobs, but because of a single, largely invisible force I call revenue cycle complexity, which inflates the time it takes to bill and collect until billing time demand outruns billing time supply. This is the foundation of everything I teach, and it is the reason a broken revenue cycle can be rehabbed.

Everything I share here is grounded in data. Where I state something as fact, it is proven by millions of claims worth of data gathered over close to a decade. Where something is my opinion, I will say so.

You're in a revenue cycle business, not a practice with a biller

Most practice owners think they own a physical therapy practice that happens to have a billing solution, whether that is an in-house biller or an outsourced company. That is the wrong frame. What a physical therapist, or any healthcare provider, does for a living is convert their time into potential revenue. Your revenue cycle functions then determine how well that potential revenue converts into cash.

Revenue cycle is everything that impacts if, when, and how much you get paid for your time. That is credentialing, patient registration, authorization management, verification of benefits, clinical documentation and the coding it supports, your policies, your payer mix, the systems you work in, and billing itself. Unless you are a 100% cash business like a plumber who trades time directly for money, you are a revenue cycle business, and the way you structure and run it should reflect that.

The three objectives every revenue cycle shares

Every revenue cycle has the same objectives, no matter the specialty. There is a pre-objective and three that follow, and they are uniform whether you are a physical therapy practice or a hospital system.

First, convert provider time into the highest potential revenue your structure allows. Then collect all of that potential revenue, 100% of what your structure allows you to be paid. Collect it as fast as possible in calendar days. And do all of it as cost-effectively, which really means as efficiently, as you can. Anything that creates a shortfall against any of those objectives, I call an objective risk. Objective risks are the things standing between you and the money you have earned, and they can be quantified if you understand and measure time correctly.

Why revenue cycles break: billing time demand versus billing time supply

At its core, revenue cycle is about creating balance between what I call billing time demand and billing time supply. Simple concept, very difficult to do.

Billing time demand is driven by two variables: the volume of work, and the complexity inside that volume. Billing time supply is the time you actually have. If you have one biller, that is your supply. If you outsource to a company that charges a fixed percentage of revenue, they convert that fee into a time budget and will not spend more time than that budget allows. Almost the entire industry runs on fixed time supply, and the entire industry focuses on the supply side of the balance. I have spent close to ten years focused on the demand side, because that is where the real problem lives. When demand exceeds supply, outcomes suffer. Every time.

Here is the fact that surprises people. Volume is not the main driver of time. Across our millions of claims, once we normalize for volume, the time variance from our least complex clients to our most complex clients is about 1,000%. I have a 1,000-visit-a-month client whose billing takes five times as much time as a 10,000-visit-a-month client. It is not the volume. It is the complexity in the volume.

Revenue cycle complexity is a black hole

I read a lot of black hole science, so the analogy comes naturally. A black hole is invisible. You cannot see it directly, yet it exerts enormous force on everything around it, and it consumes without limit. Revenue cycle complexity is the same. It is hard to quantify and invisible in the moment, but it has tremendous impact on if, when, and how much you get paid.

Left unmeasured, complexity inflates billing time demand, and that inflation shows up first and worst in your accounts receivable. So the most important work in any revenue cycle is understanding what drives billing time demand, then reducing the complexity that inflates it. To do that, you have to be willing to study the thing you cannot easily see.

The biller is affected by everything, so the biller can explain everything

Billing is the only revenue cycle function that is affected by every other revenue cycle function. A credentialing problem hits your biller. A patient registration error hits your biller. An authorization issue, a verification-of-benefits gap, a systems problem, a difficult payer: all of it lands on the biller, even though almost none of it is created by the biller.

That is the insight the whole model turns on. Since the biller is affected by everything, the biller is the one function positioned to explain everything. So we changed a few things about how billers spend their day, a series of roughly five-second captures that add up to maybe five to ten minutes, and we convert their experience into data. That reframes the biller from a back-office task doer into a powerful revenue cycle intelligence data generator. If you can identify a problem and measure it, you can fix it. If you cannot, you never will.

Think of your billing team as a crew team rowing for speed and accuracy. They have to row in sync, at pace, with good technique. But they did not build the boat, and they do not control the water or the weather. You can have the greatest crew team in the world, and in three-foot chop they will never perform the way they would in smooth water. Complexity is the weather. Our job is to understand and change the conditions, not to blame the rowers.

Where the complexity actually comes from: 71 / 10 / 13 / 6

We have quantified more than 270 distinct sources of complexity across millions of claims, tracking time to the minute on 50 different billing tasks for about seven years. When we roll it up, here is where revenue cycle complexity originates:

  • 71% comes from functions internal to the practice but external to billing: credentialing, authorization management, verification of benefits, patient registration, clinical documentation quality.
  • 10% comes from payers.
  • 13% comes from the systems themselves: the EMR, practice management software, and clearinghouse.
  • 6% is created inside the billing process itself.
Where revenue cycle complexity originates A single bar divided into four parts: 71% inside the practice but external to billing, 10% payers, 13% systems, 6% billing. The first three together are 94%, external to billing. 94% is external to billing 71% 71% Inside the practice, external to billing 10% Payers 13% Systems: EMR, practice management, clearinghouse — most from improper setup 6% Inside the billing process itself
Where revenue cycle complexity originates. Source: Revenue Cycle Solutions.

That means 94% of what puts your revenue at risk is external to billing. Ask a room of practice owners what their biggest obstacle to getting paid is, and they will say the payer first and billing second. Neither answer is even in the room with the dartboard. The single most important thing that distribution tells you is that the problems putting your revenue at risk are overwhelmingly created upstream, in functions that affect the biller but are not the biller.

Those sources are not equal in their power to inflate time. The function most affected by complexity is accounts receivable management, and within it, denial management is the most affected of all. When we compare our most optimized clients, who create objective risks on less than 5% of their claims, to our least optimized, who create them on more than half, the time variance in AR denial management is 4,060% per visit. That is 40 times the work for the same task. No process can be staffed or managed against a variable that can swing your time by 40 times. The only answer is to reduce the complexity that drives it.

A physical therapist's mindset, applied to your business

I do not believe I could have built any of this if I were not a physical therapist. When a patient walks in and says their back hurts and they cannot stand up straight, you know almost nothing yet. The symptom is obvious. The work is answering the why behind the what, and then changing things at the root cause so the result lasts. I cannot turn that part of my brain off, so when I moved into billing and saw broken revenue cycles everywhere, I needed to understand why.

The parallels run deep. A great patient is motivated to change, willing to learn, willing to take action, and able to communicate through the setbacks, and the two of you collaborate around a plan of care. A revenue cycle is no different. It has to be willing to look at its own root causes and change them. That is why the podcast is called Rehabbing Your Revenue Cycle. It is the same work I used to do with patients, applied to the business of healthcare. And it runs on one chain: better data leads to better process, better process leads to better outcomes, and better outcomes lead to a better business.

What this looks like over nine years

Here is one client, tracked from 2016 to 2025. In 2016 they were a physical therapy practice doing 1,477 visits a month at an average revenue per visit of $75, a little over $1.3 million in annual revenue. They broke 23% of their claims, so their revenue cycle complexity was 23 per 100 visits. Their profit margin was 8%, and at normal valuation methods the business was worth between $500,000 and $550,000.

Over those nine years, we took their complexity from 23% down to 4.8%, an 80% reduction. That complexity reduction lifted revenue per visit from $75 to $105, a $30 increase per visit, or 40%, and because it did not cost them more to earn it, that gain was essentially all profit. Their margin went from 8% to 32%, which is what made them scalable, because you cannot scale a thin-margin business. They grew from 1,477 to 5,500 visits a month, a 372% increase in scale, and to about $7 million in annual revenue.

Our model is that the better the outcome, the lower our fee, so as their complexity fell and our efficiency rose, our fee came down and their billing-cost savings alone exceeded their entire 2016 profit, roughly $140,000 a year. Put it all together and the business went from worth about half a million dollars to worth roughly $17 million, a 3,342% increase in valuation. That is what it means to rehab a revenue cycle: not just to do the billing, but to change what the business is worth.

Who this model helps

I do not care whether you outsource your billing or keep it in-house. If you outsource, we can do it for you through Revenue Cycle Solutions, and I would argue we can do it better because the approach is different. If you bill in-house, or you are a revenue cycle company yourself, Ascend Solutions can put our data platform, Practice Data Solutions, underneath your operation and convert your task-level billing process into the same revenue cycle intelligence engine. Revenue Cycle Solutions is the services company, focused primarily on physical therapy and occupational therapy. Ascend Solutions owns the platform, and the platform is specialty-agnostic and systems-agnostic.

The objectives are uniform, the problems are uniform, and they have reached pandemic levels across healthcare: downward pressure on revenue and upward pressure on cost, driven by rising complexity. None of it changes until you can measure it. Anything that matters has to be measured, and we have built a way to measure the things that determine whether a revenue cycle succeeds.

Find out where your revenue cycle stands

You cannot reduce what you have not measured, and most owners have never seen their revenue cycle complexity quantified. Every RCS relationship begins with a revenue cycle assessment that quantifies the complexity inside your practice and the opportunity to improve your outcomes, shared with you at no cost and no risk.

Request Your Free Revenue Cycle Assessment

Listen to the full launch episode (a two-part episode) on the Rehabbing Your Revenue Cycle podcast: Part 1.


Frequently asked questions

Why are most physical therapy revenue cycles broken?

Not because the people are bad at their jobs, but because revenue cycle complexity inflates the time it takes to bill and collect until billing time demand exceeds billing time supply. Most practices run a fixed time supply against a demand that is highly variable, so when complexity rises, outcomes suffer.

What is billing time demand?

Billing time demand is the total time it takes to bill and collect, driven by two variables: the volume of work and the complexity inside that volume. Complexity, not volume, is the bigger driver. Across millions of claims, the time variance from the least complex to the most complex practices is about 1,000%.

What is revenue cycle complexity?

Revenue cycle complexity is the errors, omissions, and structural issues across a practice that put its revenue cycle objectives at risk and inflate billing time. It is invisible in the moment, like a black hole, and can only be understood by measuring its impact on the work around it. RCS has quantified more than 270 distinct sources of it.

Where does revenue cycle complexity come from?

In our data, 71% originates inside the practice but external to billing (credentialing, authorization, verification of benefits, patient registration, documentation), 10% comes from payers, 13% comes from systems like the EMR, practice management software, and clearinghouse, and 6% is created inside billing itself. That means 94% of it is external to billing, which absorbs the effects of all of it.

Do I have to outsource my billing to use this model?

No. Revenue Cycle Solutions offers full outsourced revenue cycle management, and Ascend Solutions supports practices that keep billing in-house by putting the same data platform underneath their own team. The determining factor is complexity, not who does the billing.

← All articles